11 abril, 2008

To harm an individual is to interfere with his leading his own life

To harm an individual is to interfere with his leading his own life. Helping a person against his will also interferes. Therefore, a Lockean theory will impose constraints on paternalistic actions.
(...)




by Latuff


In other words, what is wrong with your harming me is not simply that you worsen my welfare but that you worsen my welfare. A moral theory that takes individuality seriously will therefore adopt a strong principle of harm avoiding. A theory like utilitarianism that does not take individuality seriously may also adopt a strong principle of harm avoiding, but if it does so it will be for a different reason, namely that harming generally results in overall welfare diminishment.

(Lomansky, in The Journal of Libertarian Studies)

No hay comentarios:

 

Roberta Gonçalves, 2007 - We copyleft it!